TUI · Luggage component
The £247k checkbox
The £247k checkbox
The majority of customers who upgrade their luggage do so for everyone in their travel party. On the TUI website, that meant upgrading each person, one at a time. The business wanted more customers to upgrade. Customers wanted fewer clicks. Could one small change give both sides what they wanted?
The majority of customers who upgrade their luggage do so for everyone in their travel party. On the TUI website, that meant upgrading each person, one at a time. The business wanted more customers to upgrade. Customers wanted fewer clicks. Could one small change give both sides what they wanted?


1 week
1 week
to complete designs
37 day
37 day
live A/B test
ROLE
Researcher, UX Designer
Researcher, UX Designer
TOOLS
Axure
Axure
YEAR
2024
2024
TIMELINE
1 week
1 week
The project at a glance
THE PROBLEM
Upgrading luggage meant changing it one passenger at a time. The larger the group, the bigger the chore.
Upgrading luggage meant changing it one passenger at a time. The larger the group, the bigger the chore.
MY ROLE
Research, design, working out the behaviour of the component, then working alongside a UI designer and developer through to a live A/B test.
Research, design, working out the behaviour of the component, then working alongside a UI designer and developer through to a live A/B test.
THE CATCH
The brief came from the business, not customers. I wanted to ensure it was a win for both parties.
The brief came from the business, not customers. I wanted to ensure it was a win for both parties.
01 · DISCOVER
One passenger at a time
One passenger at a time
The brief came from the TUI Ancillaries team, who are responsible for extras like luggage, seat selection and private taxi transfers. Their goal was simple - get more customers upgrading their luggage.
The brief came from the TUI Ancillaries team, who are responsible for extras like luggage, seat selection and private taxi transfers. Their goal was simple - get more customers upgrading their luggage.
I started looking into why customers might not be upgrading their luggage. Without sounding too dramatic, upgrading luggage on the TUI website was a chore. For a family of four, you had to upgrade each person individually, one after another. Cooking a lasagne started to feel quicker.
I started looking into why customers might not be upgrading their luggage. Without sounding too dramatic, upgrading luggage on the TUI website was a chore. For a family of four, you had to upgrade each person individually, one after another. Cooking a lasagne started to feel quicker.
Data from the analytics team showed that most customers who upgraded their luggage did it for everyone in the group. So the bigger the group, the more clicks it took. Only 5-10 seconds, but booking a holiday is already full of fiddly decisions.
Data from the analytics team showed that most customers who upgraded their luggage did it for everyone in the group. So the bigger the group, the more clicks it took. Only 5-10 seconds, but booking a holiday is already full of fiddly decisions.
That turned a business goal into a customer problem - make it quick and easy to upgrade everyone at once.
That turned a business goal into a customer problem - make it quick and easy to upgrade everyone at once.


The original design. Upgrading for a family of four would mean four separate choices.
02 · DEFINE
Button or checkbox?
Button or checkbox?
Finding research to guide the decision was harder than expected. As it turns out, Googling “how to stop upgrading luggage feel like ordering a round of drinks one drink at a time” doesn’t turn up much.
Finding research to guide the decision was harder than expected. As it turns out, Googling “how to stop upgrading luggage feel like ordering a round of drinks one drink at a time” doesn’t turn up much.
So I looked at how other platforms handle changing lots of things at once, and spotted a familiar pattern… the checkbox. Think about your email inbox. You can select emails one by one, or tick one box at the top to select them all.
So I looked at how other platforms handle changing lots of things at once, and spotted a familiar pattern… the checkbox. Think about your email inbox. You can select emails one by one, or tick one box at the top to select them all.
When I shared my designs in a review, most of the feedback pushed for a button, something like “Upgrade all passengers”. It was a fair suggestion, more obvious on the page, but raised an awkward question… what happens after you click it? Does the button change its wording? Turn into an “undo” link? Disappear altogether?
When I shared my designs in a review, most of the feedback pushed for a button, something like “Upgrade all passengers”. It was a fair suggestion, more obvious on the page, but raised an awkward question… what happens after you click it? Does the button change its wording? Turn into an “undo” link? Disappear altogether?
A checkbox doesn’t have that problem. It’s either ticked or unticked. One of the basic rules of design is that people should always be able to easily undo what they’ve just done, and the checkbox handles that naturally. So I stood by it.
A checkbox doesn’t have that problem. It’s either ticked or unticked. One of the basic rules of design is that people should always be able to easily undo what they’ve just done, and the checkbox handles that naturally. So I stood by it.


The button idea was set aside because there was no clear way to undo it.
03 · DEVELOP
Writing the rules
Writing the rules
A checkbox looks simple, but the thinking behind it wasn’t. What happens if someone has already upgraded one passenger but not the others? What if they click the checkbox but change their mind?
A checkbox looks simple, but the thinking behind it wasn’t. What happens if someone has already upgraded one passenger but not the others? What if they click the checkbox but change their mind?
I mapped out every scenario and landed on a few simple rules:
I mapped out every scenario and landed on a few simple rules:
Clicking the checkbox upgrades everyone to the next luggage option up. If customers start with 20kg, everyone would move to 25kg. If they start with 25kg, everyone moves to 30kg.
Unticking the checkbox puts everyone back to where they started.
Changing one passenger’s luggage separately unchecks the checkbox, since not everyone has the same upgrade anymore.
Clicking the checkbox upgrades everyone to the next luggage option up. If customers start with 20kg, everyone would move to 25kg. If they start with 25kg, everyone moves to 30kg.
Unticking the checkbox puts everyone back to where they started.
Changing one passenger’s luggage separately unchecks the checkbox, since not everyone has the same upgrade anymore.


Mapping out various scenarios
From there, I worked with a UI designer on the final look, and with a developer to make sure the test version matched the designs.
From there, I worked with a UI designer on the final look, and with a developer to make sure the test version matched the designs.
04 · DELIVER
37 days later
37 days later
The new design went into an A/B test with the original, with 50% of customers seeing each version. After 37 days, the results were in.
The new design went into an A/B test with the original, with 50% of customers seeing each version. After 37 days, the results were in.
an increase of 8.8% of customers upgraded their luggage, which saw a £247,000 increase in revenue, from luggage alone.
an increase of 8.8% of customers upgraded their luggage, which saw a £247,000 increase in revenue, from luggage alone.
The checkbox was rolled out to 100% and has since been incorporated elsewhere on the site.
The checkbox was rolled out to 100% and has since been incorporated elsewhere on the site.


Final design, live on the TUI website
LESSON LEARNED
Make it easier for the customer, and the business always wins too
Make it easier for the customer, and the business always wins too
© 2026 Nathan Davey



